The Australia-Asia Debating Guide
Edited by Ray D'Cruz
The Australia-Asia Discussing Guide
Modified by Beam D'Cruz
Australia-Asia Debating Guide Second copy - Feb 2003 Published by the Australian Debating Federation Suite 6th, 87-89 Flemington Road North Melbourne, Vic, 3051, Quotes Editor: Ray D'Cruz Text message by Alan Swanwick, Captain christopher Erskine, Ray D'Cruz Style: Sophie Campbell Graphic Design ISBN 0-9750546-0-0 There is absolutely no copyright with this guide. The Australian Debating Federation desires that it always be freely readily available. All or part of this guide could possibly be copied for almost any purpose. It could be translated. The sole request is that parts of information are not reproduced out of context. There should be no copyright in debate theory. Its contributors are very numerous to mention; they period thousands of years and numerous cultures. A web version of this guide exists from www.dav.com.au. Official replications of the guide may be purchased in the same web page. Please get in touch with Ray D'Cruz ([email protected] com) if you need clarification of any element of this guide, or perhaps if you would like assistance translating the guide in a language besides English.
Foreword Phase 1 вЂ“ Introduction Part 2 вЂ“ Adjudicating 2 . 1 Role of the adjudicator 2 . a couple of Functions in the adjudicator (a) Deciding which team offers won (b) Explaining factors behind the decision (c) Providing constructive feedback 2 . 3 The adjudication method Chapter a few вЂ“ Matter 3. 1 Introduction three or more. 2 The elements of subject (a) Reasoning (b) Significance 3. 3 Particular subject issues (a) Rebuttal (b) The responsibility of evidence (c) Taking audience into mind (d) Determining the quality of fights (e) Argument by case in point (f) Referrals to specialists (g) New matter from third negative speakers (h) The вЂinvalid' case (i) The вЂhung' case (j) Humorous fights 1 several 4 four 4 5 5 6 6 almost eight 8 almost eight 8 almost eight 9 on the lookout for 9 12 10 15 11 14 12 doze 12
Chapter some вЂ“ Technique 4. 1 Introduction 5. 2 The elements of method (a) Responsiveness (b) Framework 4. 3 Particular approach issues (a) Under-time and over-time messages (b) New matter by third negative speakers (c) Overemphasis of method Chapter 5 вЂ“ Manner a few. 1 Intro 5. a couple of The elements of manner (a) Body language (b) Vocal design 5. 3 Particular way issues (a) Humour (b) Personal episodes on oppositions (c) Dress Chapter 6 вЂ“ Explanations 6. you The reasons of the description (a) Figuring out the issues to be debated (b) Clarifying this is of words and phrases 6. a couple of Prohibited definitions (a) Explanations without a logical and relevant link to the subject (b) Self-proving or truistic definitions (c) Definitions which usually time arranged the debate (d) Definitions which place set the debate improperly 6. 3 Definitional arguments (a) The greater reasonable explanation rule (b) The uncommon definition guideline 6. 5 The even-if argument 13 13 18 14 14 17 18 18 18 19 nineteen 21 21 years old 22 23 23 twenty three 23 twenty four 24 24 25 twenty-five 25 dua puluh enam 26 21 27 twenty seven 27 twenty eight
Part 7 вЂ“ Marking the debate six. 1 Intro 7. a couple of Selecting a kick off point 7. 3 Dividing the points 7. 4 Identifying the margins Chapter almost 8 вЂ“ Reply Speeches eight. 1 Launch 8. two Particular respond speeches problems (a) Tagging (b) Approach (c) New matter (d) Points of data Chapter being unfaithful вЂ“ Points of Information 9. 1 Advantages 9. two Asking an area of information 9. 3 Answering a point of information 9. some Assessing points of information (a) Matter (b) Method (c) Manner on the lookout for. 5 Chairing the issue Chapter 15 вЂ“ Universe Parliamentary Style 10. you Introduction 15. 2 File format 10. a few The responsibility of proof 10. four The functions of teams and audio speakers (a) Starting Government (b) Opening Resistance (c) Final Government (d) Closing Competitors 29 up to 29 29 35 31 thirty-two 32 thirty-two 32 33 33 33 34 34 34 thirty five 36 36 36 thirty six 37 35 38 38 39 39 39 40 40 45
twelve. 5 Particular Worlds Design issues (a) Points of data (b) Role of the adjudicator (c) Panel decisions (d) Marking the debate Chapter 11 вЂ“ American Parliamentary Style eleven. 1 Launch 11. a couple of Format 14. 3 The onus of proof eleven. 4...